Blog Post

Five Things We Get Wrong About DEI

February 17, 2023

Messages from Government Leaders Harmful to Corporate Workplace Culture

In Texas and in Florida, we are beginning to see DEI at the forefront again, and it’s making national news. Ironically, these headlines are being made during Black History Month, a notable juxtaposition, and reminder to corporate leaders that education, awareness, and action must continue. Why? Because it's becoming clearer that what people misunderstand or disagree with, they attack and devalue. Our role as a DEI firm is to educate on why DEI is critical to organizational, economic and societal health. Amplifying misconceptions about the purpose of DEI is harmful, sowing immense discord. It's incredibly disappointing when misleading rhetoric and unsubstantiated messages are shared with the masses because the consequences directly impact the safety and livelihood of marginalized people.  DEI is much more than a Black or White issue or a political dividing point, although in America, we can’t seem to move past this position. Diversity, equity, and inclusion encompass an array of issues that benefit people from all walks of life. At KEIRUS, we believe we have a responsibility to respond emphatically with objective data that supports the need for continued progress in workplace diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives.


The Five Things People Get Wrong About DEI

 

1. Diversity shouldn't be a factor in talent decisions.

DEI is not a way to show favoritism to a particular group of people. It is a mechanism to ensure that everyone, especially marginalized groups, has a fair chance in the hiring, development, and promotional process. If we're going to say that diversity shouldn't be considered in hiring, we need to first look at the population demographics of these institutions and organizations to determine if it’s actually making talent decisions with fairness and equitable opportunity. How visibly diverse is the leadership team? Title VII protects certain identities from discrimination in employment decisions, but legal protection alone is not enough. The data is clear across government, educational, and corporate organizations that women and people of color are grossly underrepresented in leadership positions across all workforce sectors. Next month is International Women's Day, focusing on the continued struggles of women in areas such as equal pay. There has been improvement in representation of women in the last several years; however, women of color are grossly missing in senior leadership in corporate America. One in four C-suite leaders is a woman, and alarmingly one in 20 is a woman of color. LeanIn 2022 This low level of representation of women and people of color is a huge issue, and we haven't even scratched the surface on being able to measure the representation of person’s with different abilities and LGBTQ+ people. The fact remains, and will always be true, that talent decisions have a level of human subjectivity. DEI must remain a lens in which we evaluate talent practices and processes to mitigate the impact of biases that influence outcomes that perpetuate low representation.


2. DEI is about White people losing.

DEI creates gains and wins for everybody. It opens a pathway that prevents the door from being repetitively shut on those who are different and more likely to be discriminated against. The goal of DEI is not to punitively take away from one group of people to give to another. Instead, it aims to create equitable practices, so access does not require a martyr. When we expand our view from a limited or scarcity mindset to a powerful one of abundance, we can then recognize that there is enough for everyone to succeed. We often hear the expression “making room at the table,” in the context of DEI initiatives. A more powerful view is that the table is not at its best when diverse voices and perspectives are not intentionally present. Diverse teams outperform their peers. Research has repeatedly shown that companies with racially diverse leadership teams are 35% more likely to outperform less diverse ones. McKinsey Diversity is good for business, proven by the increased innovation when unlike minds think together. When an organization successfully achieves its performance objectives, career opportunities and greater financial rewards become more available to all. Simply put, when a company is winning, everyone benefits.


3. Diversity programs divide instead of unify or include.

At its root, DEI recognizes our sameness as humans with basic needs of safety, acceptance and belonging. We all desire to be respected, valued and included. When we respect everyone, the practice of discounting decreases. Unity or inclusion should not require a person to deny or ignore their unique identities. Underrepresented groups, through micro-aggressive words and behavior, are told that they should not be authentic because some may be uncomfortable with their uniqueness. In other words, one person’s desire to remain comfortable and in a place of power means that another person must pay a hefty price to belong. Separation and division begin when inclusive mindsets and approaches are absent, and when some groups remain comfortable at the expense of others. As we recognize our biases, we will be more aware of overcoming our natural tendencies to gravitate towards surface-level sameness to embrace others more fully. Diversity opens us up to the better part of ourselves, through self-awareness and conscientiousness. These attributes allow us to connect with those who are different so we can learn from them and lend ourselves to understanding their perspectives and viewpoints. DEI stirs up our empathetic response to connect with others in a way that allows them to be themselves without fear of harm, judgment, or mistrust. Workplace cultures transform when the foundation is built on inclusive and equitable practices.


4. Racism and other -isms are from the past; we should focus on the future.

If we do not become more informed about our past ignorance and its impact, history will continue to repeat itself. Historic inequities require us to implement policies that remedy decades of unequal access and oppression. Racism infiltrates every aspect of society, including education, government, healthcare, financial, and private sectors. As just one of many examples, racial disparity in medical treatment for women of color appears to be rising. Black women are three times more likely to die from a pregnancy-related cause than White women. The maternal mortality rate of Black women in 2020 was 23.8 deaths per 100,000 live births compared to a rate of 20.1 in 2019. The factors that contribute to this are disparities in healthcare, systemic racism and implicit bias. CDC, 2020  Hispanic Americans are prone to health inequities with one key factor being high levels of poverty.  For example, Hispanics were far more likely than White Americans to have been hospitalized or died because of the coronavirus. Pew Research, 2022 Anyone questioning if the tentacles of racism still exist in society should produce a non-racial explanation why Black unemployment rates have been twice as high as White unemployment rates since the 1960s. Even with degrees from Ivy league schools, Blacks face significantly disparate employment opportunities compared to their White counterparts.


5. DEI is optional.

This is probably one of the biggest myths about DEI. It is only optional if you desire to exist in a vacuum void of growth and opportunity. DEI impacts stakeholder to consumer buy-in. Diversity programs encourage us to step outside of ourselves and get to know the stories, backgrounds, and life experience of others. This engagement is a necessity to an organization’s reach and brand reputation. DEI is foundational and not optional for industries that care about their employees, customers, patients, and vendor partnerships. It should be a core value of our humanity.  Our nation is changing and will be completely different in 2050.  In less than 25 years, Asians will represent 9% of the U.S. population, while Hispanics will rise to reflect 29%. Those born outside the U.S. will represent 19% of our citizens. Pew Research A limited mindset prevents us from benefiting from what other cultures and communities have to offer our society, and how we provide opportunities for them will ultimately benefit our world. We cannot let status quo motivations continue as the world becomes more diverse.



What Is Critical Race Theory (CRT)?


The American Bar Association highlights that Critical Race Theory (CRT) is an action that encompasses an evolving and malleable practice, critiquing how racism perpetuates a racial caste system that relegates people of color to the bottom tiers. CRT also recognizes that race intersects with other identities, including sexuality, gender identity, and others which is not a bygone of the past. Instead, it acknowledges that the legacy of second-class citizenship on Black Americans and other people of color continue to permeate the social fabric of this nation.


Our children and future generations depend on us getting off this roller coaster ride between DEI and CRT. The anti-Critical Race Theory movement labels DEI as "unpatriotic," "discriminatory," or "indoctrination," and then its supporters follow this mischaracterization with policies and practices to silence DEI in education and change voting laws, which in fact, highlight the legitimacy of CRT. DEI and CRT are three-letter acronyms that underscore our need to understand the past and how we can remedy the ails of racism, sexism, ableism and other exclusionary practices that contribute to systemic bias and discrimination.


More than 2,400 corporate CEOs representing over 85 industries participate in the CEOs in Action pledge, a public commitment to create more inclusive workplaces. The anti-CRT tone in the public sector erodes the intentions and efforts by companies like these to attract and retain the best talent and build inclusive, growth-oriented organizational cultures.


The livelihood of every for-profit entity depends on its ability to understand the needs of its employees and customer base and develop solutions to address them. Check the data. Do your customers or clients represent only one demographic? For chagrins, let’s say this homogenous clientele is true for your organization today. How likely is your business to thrive in 10 or 20 years if it remains this way? From neurological diversity to gender expression, the world is only becoming more varied. How will business and the economy remain competitive if it is not meeting the needs of the entire society?


Our response today is urgent and requires an all-hands-on-deck approach, especially with those in leadership roles. We issue this personal and organizational call-to-action: do not waiver in your commitment and efforts to create and sustain diverse, equitable and inclusive workplaces. Today, we have an opportunity to reframe the five things’ people get wrong about DEI into a strategic mindset and behavioral approach.


We ask you to join us in pledging a commitment to these five practices:


  1. I commit to embracing my role and responsibility to build safe, respectful spaces for all employees to have a sense of belonging and value.
  2. I commit to support the creation and maintenance of diverse and inclusive teams within my organization.
  3. I commit to creating opportunities for innovation and growth through diverse and equitable hiring, training and promotional practices.
  4. I commit to providing the best value and service to my customers by understanding their unique needs.
  5. I commit to creating a culture of belonging in the communities where I work and live.


How Do You Want To Transform Your Workplace?



Employee Resource Groups and DEIB Councils

Establish and sustain an   ecosystem for DEIB that nurtures innovation, engagement and productivity. 

Get details →

Human-Centered Education and Awareness

Educate and engage employees through interactive learning experiences that help you create a culture of C.A.R.E.

Get details →

Attract, Develop and Retain Talent with a DEIB Lens

Create and sustain a diverse and inclusive workforce by equipping leaders to integrate DEIB across all talent practices. 

Get details →

Our Blog: Transforming with Care

By 183:896864358 November 18, 2024
In recent years, especially post-COVID, the word transformation has become a buzzword across various industries. Personal trainers use this word to describe the physical metamorphosis they’ll help you achieve, and organizations use it to outline how they'll leverage technology, particularly in the age of AI. Beyond physical and technological change, transformation takes on new significance in the realm of leadership—specifically, transformational leadership. We often see the term in leadership contexts, but what does it truly mean? The concept of transformational leadership has been around for quite some time, originally coined by sociologist James V. Downton in 1973. Over the years, the defining qualities of a transformational leader have evolved to become, at their core, leaders who focus on the essential needs of their followers. Today, it’s more relevant than ever. My own journey toward becoming a transformational leader was unplanned, and something I only fully recognized in hindsight. It evolved in ways I never anticipated. Around 2003, I was working for a global company as the director of corporate communications. That year, we conducted our first large-scale employee engagement survey. As we analyzed the results, some findings were predictable. Typical areas like pay and benefits ranked in the bottom quartile, representing the lowest-rated aspects of employee satisfaction. However, there was one surprising item in the Bottom 5 for employee satisfaction: a question about whether employees felt good about the company’s contributions to the community. This result was unsettling to our executive team because, truthfully, it uncovered something we had not anticipated. At the time, giving back to the community on a company level was not a priority. Somehow, I was tasked with finding a solution, and at first, I didn’t know where to start.
September 2, 2024
With the recent surge in attacks against companies with prominent DEI initiatives and the SCOTUS decision to overturn affirmative action in university admissions, many companies and their leaders are grappling with a significant dilemma: Do we fold or do we hold the DEI line?
December 13, 2023
A recent report indicates that 84% of employees expect employers to provide the training and development they need to stay relevant. Unfortunately, only 32% of employees are satisfied with the leadership development programs their employers provide. Learn how you can grow and diversify your leadership bench to help retain talent and meet business needs.
Show More
Share by: